I'm prolbably gonna get bashed for posting this, because people here tend to take it especially hard when anyone says something even remotely bad about Star Wars.... but I don't really care what you peopl think of me, so:
Battle of Coruscant
The space battle stuff looks amazing despite my concerns previously. I thought the starfighters sounded really whine-y in this scene… R2’s whistle/beep is straight from the OT… actually, most of his noises seem to be reused ones from the OT or something… R2’s jump outta the starfighter really annoys me… it is just so unrealistic and… just stupid.
Grievous
His voice still concerns me, but I think I can live with it. But the Neimoidian’s voice is just plain retarded! I mean, WTF?!?
Elevator
CG R2 looks terrible and it’s so obvious where he’s CG… and what is he doing with his arm all the time?
Dooku
Dooku’s jump is really stupid and unnecessary. It looks sooo fake and CG-ish… and I think it’s completely out of character for him.
Same Fate
Ian is great! Hayden, as in the previous clip, isn’t the best...
Invisible Hand
I love the sea skirmish feel of this scene. The Neimoidain’s voice is sooo stupid it’s annoying! CG R2...
Ray Shields
This is a nice scene… funny. R2 looks pretty good here…
Captured
Meh… seen it… an ok scene… it just looks…. Weird. Maybe its just me…
Grievous’s Escape
CG is aiight. I don’t like Greivous when he goes into his escape pod… his movements on “time to abandon ship” remind me of Sebulba’s… a sort of cheeky, up-to-no-good movement. I don’t like it.
Goodbye Old Friend
Good scene. I don’t understand why Obi Wan calls Anakin an “old friend”… I mean, they’ve just been together for, what 15 year and just been through the wars… you’d think they’d be closer than just “old friends”. That Hyperspace ring looks friggin stupid! I like the TIE fighter kinda sound on the starfighter…
Bold Move
Boga looks pretty good. I love Obi Wan’s “Hello there”
Chasing Grievous
Pretty damn good!
Mace vs. Palpatine
I didn’t like Hayden in this scene… or Sam for that matter. But I think that can be put down to seeing it out of context. I hate how Mace lifts his saber above his head ala Dooku in AOTC… it’s so stupid… you just wouldn’t do that.
New Apprentice
Meh. Ian is fabuloso!
Sidious
Ditto
Order 66
Um hum.
Utapau
Obi Wan’s ship looks weird… Bail is cool
Mustafar
Looks really good! R2's jump again, AHH! “R2, stay with the ship” haha, great line!
Vader Hologram
Ian's make up looks great here.
Tantive IV
Yoda looks really good!
Security Recordings
This will be a great seen in its entirety… Yoda looks good here too.
Showdown
Hayden’s hand movement on the line “I can see through the lies of the Jedi” bugs me…
The End
Was that JEJ?!? That will be a great scene. AHH! The Eopie! NOOO! ok, it doesn’t look too bad… at least not as bad as in TPM… Love the mirror to ANH.. but no music!
I just wanna make it clear that despite everything bad I've just mentioned there is still a lot of goood stuff there... and I'm almost certain I will immensely enjoy this film.
