BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING:
Let's forget about the expanded universe for a minute...
Focusing on the movies...



In The Phantom Menace (the movie!) we know very little about Darth Maul. He's Sidious' apprentice. That's it. He is a mystery.

Now In Episode II we learn A jedi Master named Sifo Dyas ordered the clone army. Sifo Dyas died ten years before Attack Of the Clones so he died during the events of The Phantom Menace.

Now...
Skip to Episode III. We know that Palps tells Anakin that his old apprentice was Jedi Master Sifo Dyas, the one to order the Clone Army. Sifo Dyas died during The Phantom Menace. He died before Count Dooku joined up with Sidious. He died when Maul died.

So...

Remembering what Yoda said about "Only two there are" doesn't it make sense that Darth Maul is a fallen Jedi?

Maul is Sifo-Dyas.

Please read this before posting:
http://www.millenniumfalcon.com/phpbb/v ... php?t=3447

kkthnxbye

We know that Palps tells Anakin that his old apprentice was Jedi Master Sifo Dyas

Um... what?

I don't think so.

IT's... a... spoiler. It's not like a whipped my dick out and started shaking it around and pissing people off. I'm asking you to put two and two together. Think.
It's not hard.

Read the post on the NOVEL TRANSCRIPTIONS and then show me two Sith apprentices during The Phantom Menace.

http://www.starwars.com/databank/charac ... index.html

Darth Maul was Darth Maul... Sifo Dyas is a completely seperate character.

You sir, have too much time on your hands.

EXPANDED UNIVERSE. EXPANDED UNIVERSE!
Expanded Universe stops at the door. Watch the movies.

How come my post about LoE vs. the Clone Wars cartoon got axed but this one is still here?

Stupid piece of shit.

Why are people even trying to prove him otherwise though?

Because this post is fun to make fun of!

stop posting this womanbeater you retard

Dude the link I referred you to is on the official site.

Lucasfilm has a canon they follow. If what was written in that Labyrinth of Evil novel goes against what George Lucas had planned for ROTS, it would have been changed.

As it is, since it was a more recent novel, my guess is that it in no way interferes with Episode 3... and whatever it says about Sifo Dyas is the truth.

Same thing happened when Timothy Zahn wanted to make Joruus C'Baoth an insane clone of Obi-Wan Kenobi in the Heir to the Empire books... George Lucas wasn't cool with that, so they changed the character.

i was about to say "guys quit being assholes to this guy and just explain the real story". then i noticed someone had already tried, and then i noticed his user name was "woman beater" and i decided to write this instead:

please never post here ever again, you piece of shit