Bandersnatch wrote:
Doctor When wrote:
1) Why is the Falcon so clean? It’s like something from an Abrams Star Trek film. I’m not against clean ships per se, but why this need to deconstruct an iconic ship? The inference being is that Solo is so unclean, he takes a pristine ship and makes it look like he’s being doing a dirty protest in it by the time we get to ANH.
Because it's newer in this movie that it was in the movies that take place after this story. Why would it look like a piece of junk when it was new?
This film doesn’t take place that long before ANH does it? It would make Han Solo one of the dirtiest fuckers in the galaxy (which of course he may well be) to get the Falcon that beat up and grubby in just a few years... It was never really that pristine in the EU, but of course the EU is now dead, so I get they can do their own ‘thing’. And in this version of canon, of course they can establish that the ship is ‘new’ and pristine, but it is (IMO) reflective of Lucasfilm’s seeming desire to subvert expectations rather than building narrative coherence and organic character development.
Bandersnatch wrote:
Doctor When wrote:
2) Why this constant need to misappropriate existing music/cues so badly? What has the main Star Wars theme have to do with Han Solo? Why play the Asteriod Chase cue in a scene other than to mimic an existing (probably better) one?
I agree with you there. But again, these are cues being used for trailers and tv spots. We don't know if they will be in the movie.
I was more referring to the actual scene that’s been released in the Falcon’s cockpit. The musical cues are in the actual scene i.e. ‘The Asteroid Chase’ (from TESB) and the main Star Wars fanfare. Now this may be the only instance in the film, but it just seemed out of place and too on the nose. I’m not sure if they used anything similar in Rogue One (other than the Imperial March), but this stood out when I watched that Solo scene/clip.