Inv8r wrote:
Same argument could be made about Yoda sensing Anakin was kinda pissy in AotC from halfway across the galaxy, but couldn't tell Palpatine was a goddamn Sith Lord until well after his whole plot was revealed.
I think the two are completely different. One being believable and the other not.
In Attack of the Clones you have a couple of things going on. First, Anakin is the chosen one. Only George
really knows what that means, but we can assume Anakin is a huge "force" in the force. Well... you get what I mean. When he, for the first time, unleashes his anger, someone deep in force meditation can notice that something is up. The cosmos shook with his rage perhaps?
I say the cosmos shook because the key to why Yoda knew something was up with Anakin was a voice broke through from somewhere and cried out "No Anakin! No!" I think that was the moment Qui-Gon first revealed his spirit to Anakin AND Yoda. So if Yoda did hear Qui-Gon's voice, and he heard the word "Anakin", well, of course he knew something was wrong with the chosen one. But it was vague, he didn't say "Skywalker's mom just died" or "poor Tuskens". He used the generic Jedi code words for, something is up.
Compare that to this episode. There is no single event that happens which would result in a disrupting of the force! No one dies, no one unleashes a great amount of anger (hate is what kept Maul alive, we can't assume he just got MORE angry). And even if something is happening to upset the "flow of the force" how can Yoda be SO specific? I was OK with Dooku saying "something is rising" because it is vague. They should have kept it that way.