bearvomit wrote:
has this scene ever been referenced before in any other material? shooting scripts, novels, making of's or anything? I wouldn't put it past Lucas to have recorded this thing last year. You don't really see anyone's face except Mark Hamill's chin and you KNOW he'd take the job.
Suspicious

I thought it was commonly known that the scene existed in some form from the ROTJ shoot.
Hell, I always assumed that the cave stuff with Luke and R2 at the end of SOTE was an intentional riff on this scene.
Deleted scenes? Long overdue. I dig SW deleted scenes... even though it's just a matter of time until some douchebag "fan editor" comes along and (poorly) recuts the movies to include those scenes. Anyway, I used to be totally onboard with the SE versions but when the OOT discs came out in 2006, that all changed. If Lucas was including the OOT cuts, this bad boy would be the killer app to finally force me to make the upgrades. But it's really hard to get excited about HD versions of the 2004 versions, new masters or not.
As to the Vader/Palpatine business from ESB, my reading is always going to be that both Vader and Palp knew damn good well who Luke's daddy was and they were both trying to hide their agendas from each other, even though both had a pretty good idea of what the other was up to. Palpatine wasn't born yesterday and I otherwise have a sorta hard time understanding Vader's obsessive search for Luke before and during ESB. The guy wouldn't go to that much trouble unless he already knew the truth.