The_Somnambulist wrote:
"...designed for young boys"?
WTF. Says who? There are untold droves of fan girls out there (ex.
http://www.heruniverse.com/). And rightfully so. Star Wars has proven it's for damn near everyone.
Lucas, for one. Go dig up the quotes, not that it matters.
Do chicks dig Star Wars? Of course they do. The same way they dig the Marvel movies. Blockbusters nowadays tend to have universal themes and mass entertainment appeal but don't be ignorant for the sake of your argument and ignore common sense: pew pew space action is inherently a male-driven genre the same way Rom-coms are female-driven. It doesn't mean people of the opposite sex can't enjoy genre films (and when they're done extremely well, like Star Wars, they can transcend the genre), but let's not pretend Star Wars was made to appeal to young girls, or that there are just as many female fans as there are men (or even close) because there aren't.
The_Somnambulist wrote:
"...have already reeked of social justice"?
What's wrong with greater diversity in the casting of underrepresented or malrepresented groups in Star Wars? It's a refreshing, different, smart and globally-conscious move. Especially coming from a major media conglomerate like Disney. Plus, this is space fantasy, not historical drama.
The world is a far different place than it was in 1977 when ANH was released without a single person of color in its cast except as the voice of the central villain.
Generally speaking there is absolutely nothing wrong with diversity in casting. I criticize it when it feels like it's being done for political reasons rather than in service to the story. There was honestly no reason to have a black person play Human Torch other than to say "Look: we're making a black guy Human Torch! We're inclusive! Diversity is awesome!" Remember when Man of Steel made Jimmy Olsen "Jenny" Olsen? Why again? It's basically reverse-sexism and reverse-racism, which I find more offensive.
I believe Boyega was chosen for this role as much because he is black, and Disney knows how culturally significant that casting will be given the scale of a franchise like Star Wars, than what he can bring to the role as an actor. Don't kid yourself: they're making a statement. That's why he was the first character shown in the teaser and why the iconography of this film will be Finn using Luke Skywalker's (the quintessential cinema hero, who is white) lightsaber: to signal a changing of the times and put the world on notice that it was the Walt Disney Company, in spite of its racist past, that made a black guy the central hero of a Star Wars film.
I'm sorry, but as a fan of this series I don't read Star Wars through the lens of Earthly social politics: I just want to see the drama about the Skywalker family play out in a logical way and logic would dictate that the central hero should be kin to that family, which happens to be white.
Don't make Shaft's son an adopted white kid or reimagine "Black Panther" as a white guy from a fake Scandinavian country. It isn't breaking barriers in my eyes, it's lessening suspension of disbelief.